Nathan Key

Don't Panic

​
Contact Me

WATCHMEN WEEK: Is Honesty Always the Best Policy?

3/11/2009

 

At the end of Watchmen, we're left with a really important question:

Do we tell truth and reveal the reality of the situation? or Do we keep silent and let everyone believe what they want about the things that have just occurred?

For those of you who have NO idea what I'm talking about- at the end of Watchmen, Adrien Veidt blows up New York City (and a few other cities in the movie). It's his master plan to create peace... In a world on the brink of nuclear war, he creates a bigger, badder enemy who is able to wipe them all out. The unification of fear is a powerful thing.

But for the plan to work, no one can know that it was masterminded by Adrien. They must think that it was an Alien Invasion (in the book) or Jon's frustration (in the movie).

World Peace hangs delicately on ignorance.

Rorschach, who doesn't have the ability to get beyond the black and whiteness of the issue, is bound and determined to tell the world what has transpired. He pays for it with his life.

* * *

In the Christian Bible, there's a passage where a prostitute named Rahab lies to protect the lives of some Hebrew Spies who are hiding with her in the city of Jericho. Later, in the letter to the Hebrews, the writer tells us that she is to be praised for her FAITH by hiding and protecting them.

Her lie is actually considered Faith?

It's so strange that in a book that's used to promote honesty and truthfulness (we swear on the Bible to "tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth" in court) such a contradiction would occur. I wonder if it's possibly that our understanding of truthfulness and honesty is a little smaller than what's required of us? Perhaps there's more to THE TRUTH than simply speaking accurately about events that have transpired.

Perhaps The TRUTH is bigger than a specific event?

* * *

What do YOU think?

1. If you knew that peace had been obtained through a lie- would you expose it?

2. What if it were economic gain that secured your job in a company? Would you keep silent so you could keep your company in business?


3. What a friend or a relative committed a crime? Would you make their actions known or stay silent to protect them?


4. What if (and here's the biggest Ethical Dilemma) there are Nazis at your door asking about the Jews you have hiding in your attic? Do you tell them the truth, or lie to protect the lives of those living with you?

5. When is it OK to lie? When is it wrong?

Linda
3/11/2009 11:46:33 am

Cyrus and I talk about this a lot. I feel that we live in a world where everyone has to tell their truth. We have to confront people with the truth blah blah blah. And often the truth is told really for selfish reasons. If someone has done something hurtful to you or behind your back and has then repented privately of their wrongdoing and has since then changed their ways do they need to tell that truth? Or is telling that truth just a way to rid themselves of the guilt that is eating them inside? If it will not help that person that they did the wrong to but only cause them further hurt and grief how is that good? How is that helpful? I don't think it is.

Obviously you have to think of the greater good. Is telling the truth going to help the greater good. What are your intentions? To just say you will blindly choose truth over everything else no matter what the circumstance or outcome then I think that is cowardly and frankly stupid. And then there are even greater questions what about the lies we tell our children such as Santa and fairies and magic and other make-believe. I personally think its important to have that bit of imagination and thought that anything is possible and magic is everywhere as a child... but others don't agree. Cyrus and I have gone into great discussions about that.

Anyways just my 2 cents.

Nathan link
3/11/2009 12:27:13 pm

Excellent point about Santa and fairies and such. I hadn't even thought about truth in terms of imagination and "magic" for children- but you're absolutely right to compare it in this way.

I'm not sure if we're going to do the Santa Claus thing or not- but I'm sure there will be some sort of fantasy that we indulge; be it the tooth fairy or ghost stories or the like...

I also like your thoughts about intention. Telling the truth with the intent to help rather than hurt is a really important element to this discussion.


Comments are closed.

    About Nathan

    Nathan Key likes to think about faith and philosophy and talk about it with others. He lives with his family in New Hampshire. He doesn't always refer to himself in the third person.

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.